I hated this EP. Yes, Down to Earth is good lyrically, and I like that Bieber actually has a writing credit on it, but everything else about it ranges from boring to annoying. One Less Lonely Girl is boring, and everything else is obnoxious. We've already mentioned Justin's vocals, but can we talk about how he's trying so hard to sell himself as a love god? Justin, you're fifteen and you sound like you're ten, stop trying to sound cool.

Overboard is decent, but I can't stand the rest of this album. Baby is annoying and repetitive, Eenie Meenie is reprehensible, I didn't hate Runaway Love quite as much because of some decent instrumentation, even though it's still pretty bad, and Stuck in the Moment and Never Let You Go are so melodramatic. Oh, and That Should Be Me is a nice guy anthem if I ever heard one. The other songs are just meh.